As one of the healing leads, I very much appreciate the time that many of the healers have taken to speak with me, and I hope that I was able to address most of your concerns when I spoke with Baracko and Zuworty last week.
I agree with most of the Healers in that I don't like the rotation idea. I've experienced what happens in guilds who use it firsthand, and I've found in my own experiences that it usually creates more problems than it solves. I do understand where Baracko is coming from with his reasoning, and while it may not be my first choice, as long as the rotation is done in a fair and consistent manner, that we aren't going to be 'left behind' in terms of gearing, and as long as some healers, if they want, can respec DPS to spread the 'sit out' burden on to more of the raid than just the healers, then I personally am fine with it. I believe Baracko's initial post covered most of this.
Myself, I still worry about gearing since for every piece that is not plate, I have to compete with many of the DPS in order to get it. Part of it is because of my own choices for how I want to gear my character, but I know I would be sorely upset if the spellsword dropped off Kel'Thuzad, I had the highest DKP of those who wanted it, and I was sitting outside because it was my 'sit out' night. While that is one 'selfish' example, I think it does illustrate why so many people, especially healers, have gearing concerns.
I do think Waldy also touched on something with the 'we feel like slots not people' comment that resonated with me. I think it, more than anything else, is indicative of why this has become such an unexpected firestorm. I am sorry to hear that Waldy doesn't feel like talking to us anymore, and I hope that can be fixed, but I certainly understand where he is coming from. I'm with Holyssa in that I don't come to raid JUST to see new things (though it's certainly fun when we do!) but to spend time with a group of people I have come to know and hate, er, love. I personally do NOT find the instance to be 'boring'. Yes, we rolled it pretty easily and I am certainly looking forward to new challenges... but I think that those challenges wouldn't be nearly as fun if I didn't have all of you guys to share them with me.
We're in 'easy' content right now. I say we all take the time to have fun, relax, and reforge the bonds that made our raid so much fun in the first place.
-Kadi