Exactly my point . Pets die too often to be useful, and 100ATK to your party is tons of DPS.
If you want people to have fun, play their specs and whatever thats fine... Im just giving you game reasons why innervate is used as it is. Its one thing to say "bring a shadow priest cause thats more fun for you". Its another to say that a Shadow priest fulfills a valuable raid role.
Actually, I'll disagree about paladins and fire/arcane mages, both of which I've played. Fire mages in MC can turn out comparable if not more DPS than a frost mage, but require a little more support (e.g. curse of elements to reduce some resistances). Sure, their primary school is useless against Rags and other pure-fire mobs (fire lords, etc), but they still can cast frostbolts and arcane missiles like the rest of us. They only suffer a damage hit with frost with crits, since they get 1.5x damage rather than 2x. Other than that, fireballs get full effect from +dmg gear (frostbolts get 84% of +dmg) and mobs like Mags are actually fire vulnerable...it adds up, believe me, but it takes a smart fire mage to know what school to use and when. Downside is mana efficiency, but that's not as important now that we all have evocation.
As for paladins, it's a moot argument on the Horde-side, but their buffs are very useful in certain situations. Sure, they may not be ideal for every case, but make good back-up healers and some of the blessings really do help make things easier. The downside is the nature of their buffs (timers, specifically) and trying to curb them from using their weapons
I agree. Fire mages are more useful than Beastmaster hunters, to the point where youd never say that a fire mage is a semi useless slotting. However, not being able to do appreciable dps on Rags and Geddon and let alone a lot of the trash is frusterating. Still I see what you mean by that. Im only talking about raid effeciancy from a numbers standpoint. Obviously a fire mage is a weaker choice than an ice mage for rags.
Again, if your goal is "bring what you want and have fun" then there arent any rules because whats best doesnt matter.
Pallies are in the same boat as Shamans. However since theya re backup healing most raids, including ours, are a lot more leniant on their specs. It isnt make or break like Priest or Hunter or Druid specs. As long as Pallies/Shamans slot healing gear for the raid, itts all good.