Just to clear a few things up, here is what's going on.
**EDIT**
Ok, so the last patch completely made the old version of Precasting enabled. No more messing with equiping weapon before targeting cursor appears. Now, if you equip it before the cursor appears, your concentration is broken and the spell is ruined.
**END EDIT**
Not quite, mainly this still is based upon the skill of the caster(s). For example, if you are an experienced PvP Pure Mage and fighting a less experienced PvP Precasting Mage, 9 times out of 10 the experience wins out.
And don't forget that, in order to precast effectively now, you must have a reasonable amount of dexterity, more than 25 +11 (Agility), preferably around 45-60, or innitiate the battle (whereas, unlike counter-attacking, you will instantly swing your weapon, not making contact if you dex is low for about 1-1.5 seconds).
EXAMPLE
Mage A has these skills/stats
100 STR/INT 25 DEX
GM Magery -- Evaluating Intelligence -- Meditation -- Magic Resistance -- Inscription -- Poisoning -- Wrestling
Mage B has these skills/stats
80-90 STR 80-90 INT 45-65 DEX
GM Magery -- Evalutating Intelligence -- Meditation -- Magic Resistance -- Wrestling -- Swordsmanship -- Tactics -- **Precasting**
With the recent (upcoming) changes, Mage B has a slight disadvantage to Mage A because of the inscreased strength of spells. With the lower HP, Mage B could very well lose before he knew what happened.
This is partially true, whereas the mage now has a tougher time battling the common Dex Monkey, but it still relies on the skill of the mage. A Mage is only as good as his skills, says some.
Mostly this is true, except in the case of the Lumberjacker, whereas most of his skills are already used up. He would have to remove some type of favorable skill to throw in Magery and re-balance his stats to be at no disadvantage, else he faces the risk of relying on his Greater Heal instead of potions/bandages (a common occurance on Test Center 6 tx6).
Basically, that's how I see it, but it still lies in the skill of the mage.
This is very much the case now. With merely 1 regular hit with a GM/Magic Halberd followed by your precasted FS, you now can practically kill any person within seconds.
That's what it comes down to every patch that changes any skill, isn't it?
I lost track of where I am going with this, so I'm going to end this giant post now.
(P.S. - I've been honing my PvP skills for the last few months and will readily accept any challenges from anyone new or old.)
(P.S.S. - I'm not picking on anyone with the numerous quotes, just making a few points. There were various points with the various posts here.)